6 min read

Autonomy, mastery, and purpose as AI enters the workspace

How expectations about autonomy, mastery, and purpose shape resistance, eagerness, and openness to AI at work.
Three colleagues considering a proposed AI-assisted workflow on a shared display in a modern office.

Commonwealth Bank and Klarna were two of the famous cases of companies that have made decisions to replace human work with AI and then revisited those decisions. For the business, it's merely a plan that needs reconsideration. For the people, it was a change that affected their livelihoods. Sadly, simply reversing a plan doesn't get things back exactly where they were.

Chances are we will see more such moves as the AI adoption curve progresses through the inevitable periods of excitement and disappointment. Most organizations are well prepared to deal with such fluctuations. Most humans are not prepared for the respective consequences.

Different stakes

From an organizational perspective, it's all about staying relevant, gaining a competitive advantage, and being more profitable. The fear that competitors can do more at a lower cost makes the risk of doing nothing look significant. BCG's 2026 executive survey identifies fear of falling behind as one of the main reasons CEOs are investing in AI. It's not the first time in history that anxiety forces decisions.

An individual professional doesn't naturally feel that pressure before the organization passes it down the hierarchy. And at that point, the questions they struggle with are much more pertinent. Will the work still need my experience? Will I have any input into how it's done? Where will my contribution be valued?

Daniel Pink's book Drive is an eye-opener on personal motivation and performance. Oversimplifying it, alongside pay and security, we humans care about autonomy, mastery, and purpose. For many years, those have been the very things that made us so valuable for the organizations and projects we contribute to. Now we face the question of whether AI expansion threatens or amplifies those. And the answer is far from obvious.

perceived as lossperceived as opportunity
AutonomyA system dictates how the work is doneMore can be accomplished independently
MasteryHard-earned expertise seems less valuableNew capabilities become attainable
PurposeA valued contribution seems to disappearMore time becomes available for meaningful work

These are perhaps extremes, but they show how people can value the same things and yet end up in very different positions on a change that affects them. How people perceive the change dictates how they behave. And it's their behavior that gets noticed and evaluated, not their legitimate concerns.

Behavioral patterns

The three behavioral patterns below are generalizations. They are meant to group the practical choices professionals face when AI enters the workplace.

Resistance

Defending what appears to be under threat is a very natural human response. It takes many forms, such as openly challenging the change, silently sabotaging the process from within, and influencing others who may be better positioned to act. The motivation is most often the genuine or perceived risk of degradation of the foundations of autonomy, mastery, or purpose on which the organization's precious productivity was built.

There can be a great deal of value in that opposition. A caring professional may spot a problem, challenge, or long-term implications that a proposal or a demonstration have completely missed. Their concern may be supported by operational, technical, or other specialized knowledge that is not widely disseminated across management layers.

While this applies to any change, the context of introducing AI, especially when combined with the "super intelligence" narrative and heightened expectations of performance improvements, directly challenges the very values companies claim to appreciate and reward. Such cognitive dissonance usually leads to stronger and more emotional reactions. Those, in turn, are usually seen as "negativity" and "resistance," which urge management to take measures to prevent their spread.

Eagerness

The very same "embrace AI fully" decision can have the opposite effect. Rather than a degradation of human expertise, some people will see an opportunity to gain new skills. Rather than a limitation of their autonomy, they'll see freedom from the drudgery of work. They may have no issues redefining the purpose, and they may even be more excited about the new one.

That is the enthusiasm an organization hopes to see, especially when it leads to useful applications, improved processes, lower costs, and the achievement of more ambitious objectives.

The problem arises when the hoped-for gain is treated as a fait accompli. And that has never been easier and more tempting. Not a single day goes by without another announcement of some amazing accomplishment by some AI model, autonomous agent, or intelligent application. It's not that all those achievements are fake or don't deserve attention. It's that carefully prepared scenarios within a controlled environment aimed at a wow-effect outcome are not what day-to-day operations of most companies look like.

AI eagerness could therefore be a slippery-slope attitude for professionals. It is likely to elevate one's importance initially, but it may ultimately turn the position into a "scapegoat" one.

Openness

You have every right to expect that, after presenting two extremes, this article will now state the obvious: staying in the middle ground is the best solution. That would actually be sitting quietly and waiting to see how things unfold.

Openness is different. It's allowing the idea on the table for scrutiny. It's allowing space for opportunity while pointing out the weaknesses. It's about working out where an AI capability is of value, where the existing skill is still required, or why a particular application should be ruled out.

Openness is not a slower route to compulsory agreement, though not opposing the idea when one feels threatened often seems that way. It's about making an effort to understand the intentions and the need the organization has identified, beyond the obvious instincts and assumptions. Often, offering one's "mastery" to support the initiative could grant them some "autonomy" to question the implementation and adjust the trajectory towards a more satisfactory "purpose".

AI literacy

Questioning and assessing any technology without sufficient knowledge is a recipe for appearing ignorant or mean. There is a certain level of AI literacy that allows one to ask the right "what about", "what if", and "how would we know" questions.

As of 2026, however, 69% of the participants in AISA assessments scored below their “Proficient” level. Just because everyone seems to be talking about AI, doesn't mean everyone knows how to use it properly. Personal experience with chatbots, voice assistants, and image/video generators helps, but it may not be directly transferable to the work environment.

Asking the organization to invest in employees' development to reach a sufficient level of AI literacy is therefore completely reasonable. Whatever the response, it will at minimum reveal what role people are expected to play in the change.

Preparing for the unknown

No one really knows what "professional" will mean in a few years. Defending today's definition by all means is a questionable long-term strategy. Falling for the imaginary alternative in which each of us is a supervisor of AI agents seems too detached from reality. Openness combined with professional judgment is arguably the best attitude here, but it requires proficiency in using new tools. It's rather a safe bet that most organizations will demand that in the future.

From a personal development perspective, practicing an open attitude and investing in increasing one's own AI literacy seem to be the way forward. Autonomy, mastery, and purpose remain important but must continually adapt to an ever-changing world.

All guides

Related resources

Two professionals explore a screen behind patterned glass labeled AI Fundamentals.

AI Fundamentals

Understand how AI assistants work, recognize their limits, and apply professional judgment in your work.

Your privacy choices

We use optional analytics to understand how people use Mindmile. You can accept or reject analytics, and change this choice at any time. Read our privacy notice.